Thanks for visiting! - Alex

Position vs index

Estimated reading time: 1 min

Have you ever wondered why you sometimes see index and sometimes position keywords in code fragments?

… numeric indices are not a good choice for describing positions within a linked list because, knowing only an element’s index, the only way to reach it is to traverse the list incrementally from its beginning or end, counting elements along the way.

… position, which formalizes the intuitive notion of the “location” of an element relative to others in the list.

To provide a general abstraction for the location of an element within a structure, we define a simple position abstract data type.

Be mindful that this is described within the context of Java.

This all stemmed from my reading of The Positional List Abstract Data Type. At the same time, this text was fun to read because it got linked to graphs and their traversals

The advantage of receiving a position as a return value is that we can subsequently use that position to traverse the list.

and right away they give you a traversal example (the connection to graphs is obvious if you’ve worked with them before)

Position<E> cursor = document.first();
while (cursor != null) {
  cursor = document.after(cursor);
}

This position list has a bunch of update methods that work like this

MethodReturn valueContents
addLast(5)p(5p)
addAfter(p, 7)q(5p, 7q)
addFirst(4)r(4r, 5p, 7q)
addBefore(r, 1)s(1s, 4r, 5p, 7q)
set(p, 0)5(1s, 4r, 0p, 7q)
remove(p)0(1s, 4r, 7q)

See you next time

· software engineering
👈 Stacks October 25 2018
Binary trees 👉


⭐️ Learn Node.js ⭐️